Insurance Agency in Laurel, Delaware

Looking for an insurance agency in Laurel, DE? The Insurance Market helps individuals, families, and businesses throughout Sussex County and Southern Delaware find insurance solutions tailored to their needs. As an independent insurance agency with more than a century of experience, we help clients evaluate coverage options for their homes, vehicles, businesses, employees, and more.

Our Laurel team works with you to understand your risks, compare appropriate insurance options, and develop a coverage strategy around your goals. Whether you’re looking for personal insurance, commercial insurance, employee benefits, or risk management guidance, we’re here to help.

Visit our Laurel office at 310 N. Central Avenue or contact our team to discuss your insurance needs and request a personalized evaluation.

Have questions about your coverage? Call our Laurel office today.
Call (302) 875-7591

Hours

MONDAY - THURSDAY

8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

FRIDAY

8:00 AM - 4:30 PM

SATURDAY - SUNDAY

CLOSED

Serving the Delmarva Community

Personal Insurance

We focus on improving your risk profile, not selling insurance. With over a century of experience in Personal Lines, our team has become the premier broker for placing you with the best coverage for the best premium.

Commercial Insurance

From small businesses to established organizations, our team works with you to evaluate your exposures and explore coverage options that help protect what you’ve worked hard to build. We take the time to understand your business and help you find coverage that fits your needs.

EMPLOYEE BENEFITS

We provide all-inclusive consulting for your benefits suite, that includes ensuring the health and financial protection, assistance with compliance regulations, and support for your Human Resources staff.

RISK Management

Protecting your business takes more than an insurance policy. Discover how ARMOR 360° can take a more proactive approach to managing risk, strengthening your business, and preparing for the unexpected.

The Insurance Market is proud to help individuals, families, and businesses in Laurel and the surrounding Sussex County community navigate their insurance needs. As an independent insurance agency, we work with multiple insurance carriers to help clients explore coverage options suited to their circumstances.

Whether you’re purchasing a home, reviewing your auto coverage, or looking for insurance solutions for your business, our Laurel team is here to help you make informed decisions.

FAQ

What areas does your office serve?

Our Laurel office serves individuals, families, and businesses throughout Sussex County and Southern Delaware, including Seaford, Delmar, Georgetown, Millsboro, Selbyville, and surrounding communities.

The Insurance Market is licensed to provide insurance services in 40 states, allowing us to assist eligible individuals and businesses beyond our local Delaware and Maryland communities. Whether you own property in another state, operate a business across multiple locations, or have insurance needs that extend beyond the region, our team can help you explore available coverage options. Insurance products and services vary by state and carrier.

As an independent insurance agency, The Insurance Market works with a wide range of insurance carriers, including Travelers, Progressive, Nationwide, Liberty Mutual, The Hartford, and many others. This allows us to help clients compare coverage options and find insurance solutions suited to their needs.

If you already have a policy with one of our partner carriers, we may be able to assist with updating your coverage or managing your existing policy without requiring you to change insurance companies. Our team can review your current policy and explain your available options.

For convenient access to carrier billing and payment information, visit our Carrier page.

MEET THE LAUREL TEAM

Certified Insurance Counselor
Certified Risk Manager
Certified WorkComp Advisor

Andy Hartstein, CIC, CRM, CWCA

Principal

Certified WorkComp Specialist
Accredited Customer Service Representative

Crystal Bennett, CWCS, ACSR

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Accredited Cyber Risk Advisor
Certified Insurance Service Representative
Certified WorkComp Specialist

Kristin Cline, ACRA, CISR, CWCS

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Dawn Collins

Manager, Accounting Department

Certified Insurance Counselor
Certified WorkComp Advisor

Kelly Garner, CIC, CWCA

Manager, Commercial Lines

Certified WorkComp Specialist

Jessica Hearn, CWCS

Commercial Lines SBU Lead Account Manager

Certified WorkComp Specialist

Daniela Hernandez, CWCS

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Cathy Hitchens

Accounting Associate

Bethany Johnson

Administrative Assistant

Valerie Johnson

Personal Lines Account Manager

Certified Insurance Service Representative
Trusted Personal Risk Advisor

Shelly Marino, CISR, TPRA

Manager, Personal Lines

Accredited Cyber Risk Advisor
Certified Insurance Counselor
Certified WorkComp Advisor
Certified Insurance Service Representative
Transportation Risk and Insurance Professional

Ashley Mellin, ACRA, CIC, CWCA, CISR, TRIP

Commercial Lines Account Manager
IM Anytime Ambassador

Certified Insurance Counselor
Certified Insurance Service Representative
Certified WorkComp Specialist

Terri L. Moore, CIC, CISR, CWCS

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Certified WorkComp Specialist

Janet Morgan, CWCS

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Certified WorkComp Specialist
Accredited Customer Service Representative

Haleigh Nichols, CWCS, ACSR

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Accredited Cyber Risk Advisor
Certified Insurance Counselor
Certified WorkComp Advisor
Certified Insurance Service Representative

Jessica Parrott, ACRA, CIC, CWCA, CISR

Commercial Lines Asst. Manager

Accredited Cyber Risk Advisor
Certified Insurance Service Representative
Certified WorkComp Specialist

Sherry Pusey, ACRA, CISR, CWCS

Manager, Claims

Heidi Rouane

Personal Lines Account Manager

Accredited Cyber Risk Advisor
Trusted Risk Advisor
Certified WorkComp Advisor
Transportation Risk and Insurance Professional

Kim Russell, ACRA, TRA, CWCA, TRIP

Commercial Lines Account Executive

Accredited Cyber Risk Advisor
Associate in Claims
Certified Work Comp Specialist

Charles Stanfield, ACRA, AIC, CWCS

Claims Associate

Accredited Cyber Risk Advisor
Certified WorkComp Advisor
Transportation Risk and Insurance Professional

Roger Waters, ACRA, CWCA, TRIP

Commercial Lines Account Executive

Certified WorkComp Advisor
AHIP Certified

Scott Ward, CWCA, AHIP Certified

Commercial Lines Account Executive

Sarah Young

Personal Lines Account Manager

Reviews

4.8 Over 69 Reviews
Review from Google
We have been working with the Insurance Market for years. Stephen and Ashley have helped us with our commercial and vehicles insurance policies. They make it easy and stress free! Their customer service and timely answers with questions are top notch.

We recently explored health care plans with Josh Simon and the experience was phenomenal. We went with a Sana health care plan and Colonial Life for our employees. Friendly and quick responses, seamless enrollment and even following up to make sure everything was running properly! We value their company for making ours better!
Review from Google
Crystal has been a great help supplying documents for me. Thanks Vic
Review from Google
We have been with The Insurance Market for many years now. We are extremely pleased with all of their services they provide us. They have a proactive approach and understand our business needs. Our Account Manager, Stephen Hartstein, A principle at The Insurance Market, Our commercial account managers, Ashley Mellin and Janet Morgan are absolutely amazing and efficient to work with! They are all on it! So grateful to have all of them on our team and looking out for our business! I highly recommend them!
Review from Google
Was recommended to Josselyn Lopez, has done an amazing job for me and my business! Highly recommend !